Business

Brazil’s oil exports and exploration cast a shadow on its green ambitions

Crude oil was Brazil’s top export in 2024, with China its main buyer. As it aims to show leadership ahead of COP30, its government also hopes to explore a controversial Amazon field
<p>Rodrigo Avelino, project manager at Petrobras’ Abreu e Lima refinery in Pernambuco state, on a technical visit at the plant’s facilities. The Brazilian company has been playing a key role in boosting oil exports over the last decade (Image: Fernando Frazão / Agência Brasil)</p>

Rodrigo Avelino, project manager at Petrobras’ Abreu e Lima refinery in Pernambuco state, on a technical visit at the plant’s facilities. The Brazilian company has been playing a key role in boosting oil exports over the last decade (Image: Fernando Frazão / Agência Brasil)

Last year, oil overtook soy as Brazil’s main export for the first time since 2012. According to trade data published by the government, foreign oil sales totalled almost USD 45 billion in 2024, passing soy’s USD 43 billion. The value of Brazil’s crude oil exports has more than doubled in the past five years, and has close to quadrupled in the past decade.

China is driving this demand. According to Brazilian government data, China received 44% of Brazil’s crude oil exports in 2024, followed by the US (13%) and Spain (11%). In the past decade, the value exported to the Chinese market has also grown by almost five times.

In tonnes, China’s relevance remains significant, though less pronounced. In 2024, it purchased 44% of the oil exported by Brazil. But although China tripled its demand for Brazilian oil over the past decade, its consumption is similar to that of five years ago.

According to experts, this trend could become more pronounced in the short term, due to US President Donald Trump’s initiation of a trade war with China. The Asian country retaliated in February by imposing a 10% tariff on oil from the US – the source of 2% of its oil imports in 2024 – and may likely increasingly turn to providers such as Brazil.

Brazil’s growing oil exports are casting a shadow on national climate ambitions, as well as several environmental and clean energy cooperation agreements it has penned with China. Furthermore, Brazil is preparing to host November’s COP30 climate summit in the Amazonian city of Belém; in March, President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva said the country “is at the forefront of a global ethical assessment to raise climate ambition”. But in recent weeks, the government has also been increasingly pushing for oil exploration in Brazil’s ecologically sensitive Foz do Amazonas, the mouth of the Amazon river.

This insistence on fossil fuels is raising scepticism around Brazil’s green promises.

‘Brazil is reliable for China’

China imports more crude oil than any other country. According to the International Energy Agency, this demand has grown over recent decades mainly due to China’s massive investments in industry and infrastructure, as well as its population growth and economic development. Russia and Saudi Arabia provided the bulk of China’s crude oil imports in 2023; Brazil ranked sixth.

“Brazil is a reliable country for China,” says Tulio Cariello, director of content and research at the Brazil-China Business Council (CEBC). “It’s a major producer, and has a lot of research, development and stability. The country enjoys a privileged geopolitical situation, as it is far from disputed regions.”

According to Brazilian government trade data, China has also exponentially increased its imports of refined fuel from Brazil: the amount spent climbed from USD 88 million to USD 609 million between 2023 and 2024. Dialogue Earth consulted Igor Celeste, a market intelligence manager at the Brazilian Trade and Investment Promotion Agency (ApexBrasil): “Although it’s a more incipient product on the Chinese import list, we believe – given the dynamics of growth – that there may be more opportunities or demand in the future.”

André Leão, a researcher at the Institute for Strategic Studies on Oil, Natural Gas and Biofuels (Ineep) in Rio de Janeiro, says the intensification of the rivalry between the US and China after Donald Trump’s victory could prompt Brazil to further expand its exports to China.

“From a political point of view, Brazil is also likely to exhibit a tendency to distance itself from the US, although [Brazilian] diplomacy is adopting a cautious stance. This creates an opportunity to strengthen relations with China,” explains Leão.

China is a major consumer of oil and coal and maintains a predominantly fossil fuel-based energy mix. However, China is also rapidly advancing in its transition to cleaner energy sources: national CO2 emissions are expected to peak later this year. Sinopec, the largest Chinese oil refiner, estimates that refining will peak in 2027 as domestic consumption of diesel and petrol falls.

Despite these circumstances, analysts expect Brazil’s oil exports to the Chinese market to continue growing. Cariello says Brazil’s supply will remain crucial to China, and while reducing their dependence on this market is something that “companies in the sector are aware of”, it will only occur “in the distant future”.

Financing the energy transition

Brazil finds itself holding contradictory roles as both an exporter of growing volumes of oil and a leader on climate action. According to analysts, Brazil can reconcile these positions by maintaining its defence of “common but differentiated capacities and responsibilities”. This principle, enshrined under the United Nations’ climate convention, holds that developing countries must reduce their greenhouse gas emissions, but without assuming the same targets as developed countries.

“One of the ways to reconcile this is to argue that the resources needed to make the transition come from oil exploration itself,” adds Leão.

Even in the most ambitious energy-transition scenarios, we haven’t reached zero oil consumption
Heloísa Borges Esteves, EPE’s director of oil, gas and biofuels studies

In 2024, the Energy Research Company (EPE), which supports Brazil’s energy planning, published a study highlighting the oil industry’s strategic role in energy security and investment. The institution argues that oil sustains Brazil’s economic development and its citizens’ quality-of-life standards. It also argues that oil will continue to meet demand amid global uncertainties around the pace of fossil fuels’ decline, and preserve jobs while the workforce adapts.

“Even in the most ambitious energy-transition scenarios, we haven’t reached zero oil consumption,” says Heloísa Borges Esteves, EPE’s director of oil, gas and biofuels studies. “The oil and gas industry needs to collaborate with the transition, financing the technologies we need.”

Researchers consulted by Dialogue Earth say they recognise the country’s dependence on oil, especially in the transport sector. But they criticise the government’s lack of mechanisms linking oil revenues to investments in clean sources, or to monitor such allocations.

Dialogue Earth spoke to Shigueo Watanabe Jr, a researcher and physicist specialising in climate change at Climainfo, a São Paulo-based non-profit dedicated to climate change news and research. “It’s impossible to say, ‘This item here is from royalties that the federal government earns from selling oil, and this money is being used for wind energy or public transport,’” he points out. “Without designating where the money is going, and without metrics that allow us to check whether this plan is being implemented, this story of financing the energy transition is a fantasy.”

The P-67 floating production, storage, and offloading (FPSO) vessel owned by Petrobras, anchored in Rio de Janeiro’s Guanabara Bay. Brazil has plans to expand offshore oil production, with the Amazon coast one of its main targets (Image: Tânia Rêgo / Agência Brasil)

Oil until when?

Tensions over oil exploration in Brazil have intensified in recent weeks, especially in relation to Foz do Amazonas. The project is causing divisions even within the government itself.

The oil firm Petrobras is seeking to move forward with studies to assess the viability of exploring the area. The state-owned company argues that Foz do Amazonas is crucial to keeping the country’s oil reserves stable. However, the government’s environmental agency, Ibama, recommends rejecting the project’s environmental licence. It cites potential harm to mangroves and sensitive Amazonian reefs, as well as to coastal populations.

President Lula has come out emphatically in favour of this exploration. Faced with the possibility of Ibama’s third rejection of the project, Lula says the agency “seems to be against the government”. Brasília is now reportedly considering replacing Ibama’s management.

Amid this impasse, some observers are highlighting the lack of concrete proposals to reduce Brazil’s fossil fuel dependence. Watanabe Jr says the country will continue to exploit oil unless there is “a revolution – which is unlikely”. But he adds that the government “needs to have a plan to stop burning oil at some point, as soon as possible”.

Currently, the EPE has an energy expansion plan up to 2050 that does not include clear carbon-neutrality scenarios. The government’s Climate Plan, conceived as a pathway for climate change mitigation through to 2035, has been in preparation since 2023. Its first part is due for publication this year. Until then, says Watanabe Jr, Brazil still does not have a clear plan to reduce its dependence on oil, whether for domestic consumption or export.

“Brazil today extracts more or less three million barrels of oil a day. We consume between one million and two million, and that million that’s left over, we export,” explains Watanabe Jr. “They export to make money; they get some royalties. But do you need to export all that oil? Probably not. It’s a hyper-contradiction to say, ‘let’s take care of the climate’, and at the same time increase emissions in order to have money.”

-->